Duncan’s Economic Blog

1976 and all that

Posted in Uncategorized by duncanseconomicblog on September 23, 2009

I’ve been reading quite a bit of economic history over the last few months and overl the last few days I’ve been re-reading ‘Good Bye Great Britain: 1976 IMF Crisis’ by Kathleen Burk & Alec Cairncross.I really would recommend it.

It is especially strong in putting the crisis into international perspective – the response of the US and German governments to Britain’s problems was as important as our own government’s.  What is striking is the extent to which US Treasury Secretary William Simon, about as free market as Treasury Secretaries come, used the IMF as weapon to force a policy shift in the UK.  

Aside from the international context there are some important points, relevant to today.

Last year’s large fall in Sterling is not really comparable to the situation in the 1970s. The external debt position of the UK economy is much stronger and now, as then, Sterling was falling from an overvalued position.  Perhaps most importantly Sterling is not the reserve currency it then was and there aren’t ‘Sterling Balances’ held by mainly Commonwealth countries and oil exporters that can suddenly flee.

The other major difference is the inflation situation. 1976 was a crisis characterised by high inflation, the current economic problem is characterised by low inflation. This makes the required response very different.

The Callaghan ‘you can’t spend your way out of recession’ speech is often quoted by the right now, aiming to ‘prove’ that last year’s fiscal stimulus was a bad idea. It’s important to get the context right. The speech was far more aimed at appeasing American opinion than at a domestic audience – President Ford apparently congratulated Callaghan on ‘a helluva speech’.  Callaghan himself later stated that he was never arguing against deficit financing in a recession.

Figures, forecasts and statistics can be wrong. Estimates of the PSBR (public sector borrowing requirement) were widely off the mark in 1976/77. The result was that Healey tightened fiscal policy far more than was necessary. What will be the deficit in 2010? I honestly don’t know, probably a large one but to start making judgements and allocating cuts now based on such an imprecise estimate risks repeating the same mistake.

The Cabinet in 1976 was fully aware that the public spending cuts would damage the economy. Benn from the left articulated the Alternative Economic Strategy as a response (actually much praised in Andrew Gamble’s work), Crosland instead argued for increased spending and possibly limited import controls. The failure of the Crosland and Benn camps to unite is a great lost opportunity.

In the end the Cabinet surrendered to ‘the markets’. Monetary targets and spending cuts (plus asset sales) were accepted purely to appease market opinion. The result was  a deeper recession and the breaking of the social contract that led, indirectly, to the winter of discontent.

The simple fact is that market opinion is changeable and often wrong. In 1976 the Government backed down rather than fighting. I worry we are being pushed into making the same mistake today.


2 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. […] restarts.  The Bank has released its minutes.  Duncan has written an excellent blog about 1976 and all that which makes me need to buy yet another book on that (Healey’s own biog […]

  2. 2010 is not 1976 « Freethinking Economist said, on September 23, 2009 at 9:12 pm

    […] by freethinkingeconomist in Uncategorized. Leave a Comment I’ve reread Duncan’s post about 1976. It seems to imply the idea – “Look, capitalists/market-nutters fooled […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: